Quick answer
Buy the Ultimate April O'Neil figure first if you collect 7-inch scale and want a single character that anchors a TMNT movie shelf. Choose the They Live Alien 2-Pack first if you prefer larger clothed figures and want two display pieces in one purchase.
Scale and shelf footprint
The April figure is 7-inch scale, while the They Live aliens are 8-inch clothed figures. That inch changes how they sit next to the rest of your collection: April fits naturally with most standard action figure lines, while the aliens take up more vertical space and read as a slightly larger display piece.
If your shelf is already built around 7-inch figures, April will look consistent without reorganizing. If you have open space above or beside larger clothed figures, the 8-inch aliens can fill it without looking out of place.
One character vs two figures
April is a single-character purchase, so your display depends on how much you want that specific reporter. The They Live set gives you two aliens in one box, which is useful if you want an instant pair or a small scene rather than a lone figure.
That difference matters for budget and pacing. One figure is easier to slot into an existing collection; a two-pack gives you more figures per purchase but commits more shelf space at once.
Price and value trade-off
At catalog prices, April is listed at USD 26.97 against a comparison price of USD 37.99, and the They Live 2-pack is USD 44.84 against USD 64.99. The two-pack costs more in total, but it covers two figures, so compare the per-figure cost rather than the sticker price alone.
Neither product record lists accessory counts or articulation details, so don't assume either set includes extras beyond what the catalog shows. If accessories are a deciding factor, check the product page before ordering.
Trade-offs to weigh before you buy
- Scale consistency: April's 7-inch scale blends into most standard figure shelves; the 8-inch aliens stand taller and may need their own space. Measure your shelf height before choosing the 8-inch set.
- Figures per purchase: April gives you one character; the They Live set gives you two aliens in a single box. Decide whether you want a focused single-character display or an instant pair.
- Upfront cost: April is the lower total at USD 26.97, while the 2-pack is USD 44.84 for two figures. Compare cost per figure if budget is the deciding factor.
Product facts at a glance
- Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (1990 Movie) - Ultimate April O'Neil 7" Scale Action Figure: Ultimate April O'Neil is a 7-inch scale figure based on the 1990 Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles movie. The 7-inch scale makes her easy to display alongside standard action figure lines without a separate shelf.

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (1990 Movie) - Ultimate April O'Neil 7" Scale Action Figure - They Live - 8" Clothed Action Figures (Alien 2-Pack): The They Live set is an 8-inch clothed Alien 2-Pack, described as the first time the aliens appear in action figure form. Two larger clothed figures in one box give you a ready-made pair, but they need more display room than a single 7-inch figure.

They Live - 8" Clothed Action Figures (Alien 2-Pack)
Which should you buy first?
Choose April O'Neil first if
- You collect 7-inch scale figures and want a TMNT movie character
- You prefer a single, focused display piece at a lower total price
Choose the They Live 2-Pack instead if
- You want two larger clothed figures in one purchase
- You have shelf space for 8-inch figures and prefer a paired display


